Why the smallest line items on a statement can tell the biggest story.
In my last entry, I wrote about financial triage, about holding back a “brilliant” idea because my client needed something simpler first. This entry is triage too, just a different flavor: a lesson in subscription scams and the charges that hide in plain sight. No sophisticated strategy. Just a stack of statements, a cell phone, and a printer that didn't exist.
Recently I sat down with a new pro bono client, a gentleman in his mid-80s, along with his wife, also in her 80s, and their daughter. On the surface, the couple had a good system. Most of their day-to-day spending went on one credit card, paid automatically each month from their joint checking account. Simple, and it worked for them.
Then we started going through the statements together. What caught my eye wasn't anything big. It was a long list of small, recurring charges, most of them billed through his phone as "subscriptions," with almost nothing on the statement to say what was being bought. So, the four of us started digging.
What We Found
Antivirus software, then more antivirus software. Three security subscriptions protecting one phone from, as far as I could tell, each other. Streaming services for multiple movie services that they didn’t watch or remember. Cloud storage from more than one company. And a printer app charging about $7 a week for a printer he didn't own. Some charges came weekly, some monthly, and a few landed several times on the same day. Some were legitimate services that could have been used once or twice. Others???
His daughter opened the subscription settings on the phone while we all looked together. Nobody touched a password, and nobody took over. Every decision was theirs. When we added it all up, it came to at least $4,500 in annualized charges, many of which we were able to eliminate.
His first reaction was disbelief. His second was defensive, and honestly, I understood it. He wasn't buying apps for fun. He was protecting his photographs, his emails, his personal information. Messages kept telling him his storage was full, his protection had expired, or something important would be lost unless he acted immediately. So he clicked and he paid from the saved card on his phone, often not realizing he'd already agreed to the same thing before.
Here's the thing: those messages are good. They're designed to be. I get them too. Cloud storage full, Amazon account suspended or payment rejected etc. Just yesterday, an official-looking email told me my AAA membership couldn't be renewed because my card had been declined. One small problem. I don't have AAA. I've been jump-starting my own cars since Jimmy Carter was President.
I'll admit something: I haven't always been so quick. Years ago, I fell for one myself. My card was compromised almost immediately. Fortunately, I was alerted before anything happened, but it was enough. Now I scrutinize every email and text that asks me to do something. So when someone is less comfortable with technology, and the fear of losing family pictures is bigger than the instinct to question a message, I know exactly how clicking yes happens.
Let's Just Clean It Up
So the conversation went something like this: Yep, I’ve seen this before. No judgment. Anyone could react the same way. Let's fix it. And we did. We confirmed the cancellation of almost ten subscriptions and deleted the apps. We closed a PayPal account and removed the stored payment information. We didn't spend time chasing money already spent. The point was to stop the next charge, not relitigate the last one.
Then we talked about warning signs like emails demanding immediate action and texts threatening to suspend an account. We talked about sender addresses that look official until you read them closely and the one rule that covers most of it: don't click the link. Go to the company's website or app yourself, or call a number you know is real, and confirm the problem exists before you do anything.
Someone in Your Corner
Their daughter turned out to be one of the most important people in the room. Someone they trusted who could help them navigate the technology, and someone who would know what to look for the next time. And that $4,500 a year? It can now go toward things that matter to them: time with family, future healthcare costs, or just a little more breathing room.
This afternoon also changed how I'll start with every new client. A credit card statement isn't glamorous planning, but it may be some of the most useful. From now on, a walk-through recurring charges, and a conversation about suspicious emails and texts, is part of the first meeting.
From Here Forward
So here is where we are. Multiple subscriptions gone, one PayPal account closed, and a couple who now pause before they click. I don't know whether the next "your storage is full" message will get clicked anyway. Probably at least one will. But now they have someone to call first.
Pro bono planning doesn't have to be a long relationship to matter. Sometimes it's one afternoon, a stack of statements, and the right people sitting at the table. For me, that's becoming the real measure of this work. Not simply the dollars saved, but the confidence gained. The impact, not the hours.